Dear Members of the Harvard Community,
I write today to update you on the full review of Jeffrey Epstein’s connections to the University, which I requested in September following a partial review of his donations to Harvard. This morning, Diane Lopez, Vice President and General Counsel, transmitted to me the cover letter appended below, along with the final report. The report confirms that the University received a total of $9.1 million in gifts from Epstein between 1998 and 2008 to support a variety of research and faculty activities, and that no gifts were received from Epstein following his conviction in 2008.
Several recommendations are made in the report, and I have instructed members of my senior leadership team to begin implementing them as soon as possible. Provost Alan Garber, in his capacity as chair of the Gift Policy Committee, is leading an effort to clarify and expand procedures related to the review of potential gifts, and Vice President Brian Lee will work to ensure that those procedures are reflected in the general practices of alumni affairs and development staff working throughout the University. I have also asked Dean Claudine Gay to respond to those aspects of the report that relate directly to the Faculty of Arts and Sciences.
A separate review found that $200,937 of gifts received from Epstein remained unspent. In line with the commitment I shared in September, those funds have been divided equally between My Life My Choice, based in Boston, and Girls Educational & Mentoring Services (GEMS), based in New York. These organizations support victims of human trafficking and sexual assault, and Harvard is proud to support their important and valuable work.
As I noted last semester, we will always do our best to improve. I am deeply grateful to Diane and her colleagues for undertaking this critically important work on behalf of our community. The report issued today describes principled decision-making but also reveals institutional and individual shortcomings that must be addressed—not only for the sake of the University but also in recognition of the courageous individuals who sought to bring Epstein to justice.
Dear President Bacow:
On September 12, 2019, you issued a message to the Harvard community concerning Jeffrey E. Epstein’s relationship with Harvard. Your message rightly condemned Epstein’s crimes as “utterly abhorrent . . . repulsive and reprehensible,” and expressed “profound regret” about “Harvard’s past association with him.” You noted that a preliminary review of Epstein’s donations had indicated that Harvard did not accept gifts from him after his 2008 conviction for crimes related to solicitation of minors for prostitution, and you asked for a further review of Epstein’s donations to Harvard, as well as a review of the circumstances surrounding Epstein’s appointment as a Visiting Fellow in Harvard’s Department of Psychology in 2005.
In order to conduct this review, I engaged outside counsel to work with me and one of my attorneys in the Office of the General Counsel.1 We have completed our review and enclose our report which sets forth information regarding the process we followed; our findings; and recommendations based on those findings. Each is also discussed briefly below. I note that our findings confirm that Harvard University did not accept donations from Epstein after his conviction in 2008. We further find that this was based on deliberate decisions not to accept gifts from him made by senior Harvard officials who recognized the aberrant and unacceptable nature of his conduct.
In conducting our review, we interviewed more than 40 individuals from within and outside the University and collected and conducted targeted searches and reviews of more than 250,000 pages of documents, including email records obtained in accordance with Harvard policy. Following up on your message, I sent a communication to the community providing a mechanism for individuals to share information on either an identified or an anonymized basis. We received reports through those systems and followed up on the issues raised in those communications as well. I am grateful to all those who came forward to provide information for our review.
Our review addresses three principal areas of focus: (1) Epstein’s donations to Harvard; (2) his appointment as a Visiting Fellow; and (3) his relationship with the Program on Evolutionary Dynamics, a program within Harvard’s Faculty of Arts and Sciences that Epstein initially funded.
Based on our review, we determined that prior to his 2008 conviction, Epstein donated $9,179,000 to support Harvard faculty and programs, with the vast majority of those donations occurring before his 2006 arrest. These gifts were made between 1998 and 2007, and typically ranged between $10,000 to $200,000. Epstein did, however, make one substantially larger gift of $6.5 million in 2003 to help create Harvard’s Program in Evolutionary Dynamics. During the years before Epstein’s criminal activity became known to the public, various Harvard faculty and administrators pursued donations from him, knowing he was a wealthy individual interested in science and philanthropy. Some members of the Harvard community continued their relationships with Epstein even after his conviction, but these relationships in and of themselves did not violate Harvard policies.
In 2008, shortly after taking office as President, Drew G. Faust was asked to consider a new gift from Epstein. Though she had not heard of him at the time, after she was briefed on the nature of the allegations against him, she determined that Harvard should no longer accept gifts from him. In 2013, several faculty members requested that Harvard reconsider accepting donations from Epstein. That request was put before then-Dean of the Faculty of Arts and Sciences, Michael D. Smith, who, after being briefed about Epstein, reached the same conclusion as President Faust, and denied the request to entertain the possibility of gifts from Epstein. In his interview, Dean Smith explained that he concluded at the time that it would be inconsistent with Harvard’s commitment to address sexual assault and harassment at our institution to accept gifts from Epstein.
Following his conviction in 2008, Epstein did continue efforts to interest other donors in supporting research at Harvard. We understand, for example, that an FAS faculty member and a Harvard Medical School faculty member both received funding from donors who were introduced to these scientists by Epstein. With respect to one of these donors, we established that Epstein or his associates helped to facilitate the gift transactions, as more fully described in the report. But that donor, an alumnus with a history of giving generously to Harvard, as well as the other donor, agreed to cooperate with our review, told us their donations were based on their independent decisions to support the research and that the gifts were made with their own money. Our review did not reveal information that would establish anything to the contrary. Nevertheless, development officers at Harvard knew about Epstein’s continued involvement in encouraging others to donate to Harvard and did not take steps to discourage these efforts despite knowing that gifts would not be welcome from him. No one violated any Harvard policy in this regard, as there is none; a matter we recommend be rectified.
As to Epstein’s appointment as a Visiting Fellow, the initial appointment occurred in 2005, before Epstein’s arrest. The Visiting Fellow designation is now, as it was in 2005, granted to an independent researcher registered with Harvard’s Graduate School of Arts and Sciences as a graduate research student. In 2005, the Chair of the Psychology Department, Dr. Stephen Kosslyn, recommended Epstein’s admission. Between 1998 and 2002, Epstein had donated $200,000 to support Dr. Kosslyn’s work. The Visiting Fellow application process does not inquire about possible conflicts of interest and the fact of Epstein’s donations was not disclosed in the paperwork submitted by Dr. Kosslyn in support of Epstein’s application. After reviewing these records, we conclude, and no one argues to the contrary, that Epstein lacked the academic qualifications Visiting Fellows typically possess and his application proposed a course of study Epstein was unqualified to pursue. Epstein’s application was, nevertheless, approved, having been supported by a department chair. Epstein paid the tuition and fees to be a Visiting Fellow and showed up for registration, but we understand he did very little to pursue his course of study. Nevertheless, he applied to be re-admitted for a second year, the 2006-2007 academic year, and was again admitted, but he withdrew from that appointment following his arrest and before the new academic year began.
The third area of focus from our investigation was Epstein’s relationship with the Program for Evolutionary Dynamics. As noted above, Epstein initially funded the program in 2003 with a gift of $6.5 million. Epstein maintained a relationship with the director of the PED, Professor Martin Nowak, over the next 15 years, including after Epstein’s release from prison. While we have not been able to determine the precise number of campus visits, we understand that Epstein visited the offices of PED in Harvard Square more than 40 times between 2010 and 2018. We did not find evidence that Epstein engaged with undergraduate students during these visits (or during his time as a Visiting Fellow). Instead, Epstein used these visits principally as opportunities to speak with prominent faculty from the Cambridge area, many of them Harvard faculty. While inviting Epstein to campus did not violate any Harvard policies, aspects of his relationship to the PED, such as his access to the program’s offices, treatment on the PED’s website and interactions concerning one grant application, do implicate Harvard policies and our findings and recommendations address these issues.
Based on our review, we recommend that Harvard consider improving aspects of its operations in three respects and consider the appropriateness of certain personnel actions. These recommendations are explained in more detail in the report. I summarize them below:
- At your direction Harvard already has created a reporting relationship between school-based fundraising officers and the Vice President for Alumni Affairs and Development, and we support this action. With respect to decisions made by Harvard not to accept a particular gift, or gifts from a particular donor, these decisions need a more formal communication mechanism and better definition about the nature of the relationship with the individual once the decision is made. Development officers throughout Harvard, as well as any faculty who have received support from a person who has become ineligible to give, need to be informed more formally of such decisions and whether such decisions are irrevocable or time-limited.
- Harvard’s Gift Policy Committee should expand the universe of gifts and donors to be evaluated and communicate the criteria for review to faculty members, department chairs, deans, and development staff. We understand that the GPC is preparing a gift policy guide for the Harvard community, and we support that effort to more plainly communicate the values and standards that underpin our gift processes to all involved in fundraising at Harvard and to our alumni and donor communities.
- In terms of Visiting Fellows, we recommend that the Faculty of Arts and Sciences consider developing further controls to evaluate Visiting Fellows and ensure that any conflicts or potential conflicts of interest are disclosed and that candidates who pose a conflict or lack basic qualifications are independently reviewed as part of the approval process.
- The Faculty Affairs Office in FAS and/or the FAS Associate Dean for Human Resources should determine whether the actions disclosed in this report concerning the PED constitute violations of Harvard’s policies, and if so, what further action should be taken. The attached report provides additional information regarding these findings and recommendations.
- I look forward to answering any questions you may have.
Diane E. Lopez
Vice President and General Counsel
1 It was not necessary for the Harvard Corporation to engage independent counsel for this review because none of the officers or other relevant senior officials currently in office made any decisions regarding accepting gifts from Epstein, given the 2008 decision not to accept gifts from him. Since 2008, the incumbents holding the positions of President, Provost and Vice President for Alumni Affairs and Development, to name a few, are new. I was a line attorney in the Office of the General Counsel from 1994 to 2011 (University Attorney) with no particular responsibility for advising about gift acceptance.
Little Saint James, U.S. Virgin Islands.
|Area covered||0.28–0.32 km2 (0.11–0.12 sq mi)|
Jeffrey Epstein's former home on the island of Little St. James in the U.S. Virgin Islands on March 23, 2022. A nine-figure settlement between the estate of Jeffrey Epstein and the US Virgin Islands has been signed, according to the islands' attorney general.What is the program for evolutionary dynamics Harvard? ›
The Program for Evolutionary Dynamics is a graduate department at Harvard University. Under the direction of Martin Nowak, an evolutionist and professor of mathematics and biology at Harvard, the Program studies the evolution of molecular biology with the primary use of mathematics.How much is Jeffrey Epstein island worth? ›
Epstein's estate agreed to pay the territorial government $105 million in cash and half of the proceeds from the sale of Little St. James island where Epstein owned a home and authorities allege many of his crimes took place. The estate also will pay $450,000 to repair environmental damage on Great St.Who bought Epstein townhouse? ›
The buyers, Michael D. Daffey, a former Goldman Sachs executive, and his wife, Blake Daffey, paid $51 million for the townhouse, a steep discount from the original asking price.How much money did Epstein give Harvard? ›
The second was the mockery made of academic standards when, after donating $200,000 to the psychology department, Epstein was appointed as a visiting fellow there despite a complete lack of appropriate academic qualifications.How many islands did Epstein own? ›
Update June 2022: As reported by the Wall Street Journal, Jeffrey Epstein's two private islands in the Caribbean—Great St. James and the infamous Little St.What kind of teacher was Epstein? ›
Epstein, from Brooklyn, was just 21 when he joined the faculty at Dalton, arriving without a college degree. The school's student newspaper reported in September 1974 that he was starting that year as a math and physics teacher.Who owns the Virgin Islands? ›
The U.S. chose the name "Virgin Islands" when it took formal possession of the Danish West Indies on March 31, 1917. The U.S. bought the islands from Denmark for $25 million.What happened to Jeffrey Epstein's properties? ›
The Palm Beach mansion was also sold in 2021, for $18.5 million, and is being razed and replaced, the Palm Beach Daily News reported. Jeffrey Epstein's palm beach mansion. Epstein's Paris apartment is still on the balance sheet and has been listed for $14 million, according to the Telegraph.
United States Virgin Islands, also called U.S. Virgin Islands, organized unincorporated island territory of the United States, situated at the eastern end of the Greater Antilles, about 40 miles (64 km) east of Puerto Rico, in the northeastern Caribbean Sea.Is evolutionary psychology legit? ›
As many observers have pointed out, evolutionary psychology is largely based on assumptions rather than evidence, and as such it is debatable whether it should be referred to as a 'science' (since its hypotheses are generally unfalsifiable).What is the best program at Harvard? ›
- #5. in Best Business Schools (tie) ...
- #2. in Best Education Schools. ...
- #21. in Best Engineering Schools (tie) ...
- #4. in Best Law Schools (tie) ...
- #1. in Best Medical Schools: Research. ...
- #9. in Best Medical Schools: Primary Care.
- #1. in Biological Sciences (tie) ...
- #1. in Biostatistics (tie)
|Died||July 4, 2021 (aged 92)|
|Alma mater||Harvard University (BS) Columbia University (MS, PhD)|
|Known for||Evolutionary biology Population genetics|
In March 2021, former Goldman Sachs executive Michael Daffey purchased the home for $51 million, with proceeds from the sale going to the Epstein Victims' Compensation Program.Who is the billionaire that owns his own island? ›
Billionaire Larry Ellison owns an island in Hawaii. 98 per cent of the island of Lanai is his property.How much does private island cost? ›
Prices can range from approximately US $500,000 for a 0.5 to 1 acre undeveloped private island up to US $10 to $12 million for larger 60 to 70 acre islands, often with some infrastructure and development in place such as existing homes, docks, roads and airstrips.Who owns the Vanderbilt Mansion on 72nd Street? ›
The new owners of the co-op are Brian Hagiwara and Bret Baughman.Why is Epstein's mansion being demolished? ›
It was more of a practical decision. “We would have knocked it down either way,” said Glaser. The plan for the property is to build an Art Moderne house and put it on the market for about $40 million. “There are $50 million buyers and no houses for them to buy,” said Glaser.What is the most expensive house NY? ›
A recently listed Manhattan penthouse is being billed as the tallest and most expensive home in the world — and the amenities packed throughout this three-story unit make the $250,000,000 price tag seem almost reasonable.
Harvard University has received one of its largest private gifts in history - $350 million from billionaire entrepreneur Hansjörg Wyss, for the Wyss Institute for Biologically Inspired Engineering.How many billionaires came from Harvard? ›
With 11 billionaire grads, Harvard shares the number two rank with Yale University. Some billionaire alumni at Harvard include the Los Angeles Clippers owner and former Microsoft CEO Steve Ballmer and the founder and CEO of Citadel, Ken Griffin.Why does Harvard have so many billionaires? ›
Harvard selects students with higher expected earnings. Harvard selects students from families who are already wealthy (more than other top schools: the wealthy alumni are not self-made). Students who aspire to make a lot of money choose Harvard (over other top schools).What was Jeffrey Epstein's island? ›
James, the private island that was owned by Epstein and was allegedly a major hub for his yearslong criminal sex trafficking enterprise, said the Virgin Islands Department of Justice.How many Epstein brothers are there? ›
The Epstein Brothers—Max (1912- 2000), Willie (1919-1999) and Julius (1926-2015), were one of the top klezmer bands from the 1930s to the 1970s, when they retired to Tamarac, Florida.What was the original business of the Epstein family? ›
After Harry and his brother Leslie had joined the family firm, Isaac Epstein founded Epstein and Sons. He then enlarged the furniture business by taking over adjacent shops at 62/72 Walton Road to sell a range of other goods, such as musical instruments and household appliances.Who was the first Epstein accuser? ›
idealistic. Teachers are natural visionaries and dreamers, for they have an extraordinary imagination. What occurs in their imagination is so strong that their thoughts and feelings can often feel more real to them than what they feel with their physical senses. Ideality is often preferred over reality for them.Who was George Epstein? ›
As a graduate student/research fellow at MIT, George Epstein studied the effects of elevated temperature on structural adhesives. Later at North American Aviation, he developed the first high temperature structural adhesives. This technology is used today in film adhesives in aircraft and space systems.Do you need a U.S. passport to go to the Virgin Islands? ›
If you are a U.S. citizen a passport is not required, but it still serves as the best identification when traveling. Otherwise, you must be prepared to show evidence of citizenship when departing the islands, such as a raised-seal birth certificate and government-issued photo ID.
English is the official language, but Spanish is common. Creole (a blend of African, Danish, Spanish, English, and Portuguese) is also widely spoken.Are Virgin Islanders U.S. citizens? ›
History & Political Status
U.S. citizenship was conferred on U.S. Virgin Islanders in 1927. Federal authority over the new U.S. territory was placed in the Department of the Interior in 1931, where it resides.
Purchased by Epstein in 1993, Zorro Ranch is an expanse of desert land situated about 35 miles from Santa Fe and punctuated with a grand 30,000-square-foot mansion.Where did Jeffrey Epstein have a house in Florida? ›
The property, located at 358 El Brillo Way, was built in 1952 and purchased by Epstein in 1990.Who was Epstein's business partner? ›
Wexner had a very close relationship with Epstein that began in the 1980s and continued until Epstein's death. Wexner was once the “main client” of Epstein's money-management firm, according to Bloomberg. Wexner allowed Epstein to run his business out of a house he owned and resided in whilst CEO of Victoria's Secret.What islands do the U.S. own? ›
- American Samoa.
- Commonwealth of the Northern Mariana Islands.
- Federated States of Micronesia.
- Republic of the Marshall Islands.
- Republic of Palau.
The islands remained under Danish rule until 1917, when the United States purchased them for $25 million in gold in an effort to improve military positioning during critical times of World War I.
Visiting by Air from the United States. There are two major airports in the Virgin Islands; the Cyril E. King Airport on St. Thomas and the Henry E.How much did the US pay for the U.S. Virgin Islands? ›
History & Political Status
In 1917, the United States purchased the Danish part for $25 million, mainly for strategic reasons to assure tranquility in the Caribbean Ocean. U.S. citizenship was conferred on U.S. Virgin Islanders in 1927.
Unlike the privately-owned Little Saint James, Dog Island is owned by the U.S. Virgin Islands government.
Tensions with Virgin Islands Governor Over Epstein Led to Attorney General's Firing. Denise George, who led a three-year investigation into the activities of Jeffrey Epstein, was fired recently.Where did Jeffrey Epstein live in Florida? ›
Jeffrey Epstein's Palm Beach home located on El Brillo Way. Epstein paid $2.5 million for this Palm Beach house back in 1990.Do US citizens pay taxes in the Virgin Islands? ›
The USVI has its own income tax system based on the same laws and tax rates that apply in the United States. An important factor in USVI taxation is whether, during the entire tax year, you are a bona fide resident of the USVI.Was there slavery in the Virgin Islands? ›
In fact, the islands were a huge market for the slave trade, with thousands of slaves being shipped there from West Africa, sold, and then transported all over the Caribbean and the wider Atlantic world. Descendants of these enslaved African people make up the vast majority of the territory's population today. St.Do people in the U.S. Virgin Islands pay taxes? ›
The U.S. Virgin Islands uses a mirror system of taxation, also known as the “Mirror Code,” meaning that USVI taxpayers pay taxes to the Virgin Islands Bureau of Internal Revenue ("BIR") generally to the same extent as U.S. taxpayers would under the Code to the U.S. Internal Revenue Service.What celebrity owns a private island? ›
Even Steven Spielberg has two islands in Madeira Archipelago, off the coast of Portugal. Also, George Clooney and wife Amal Alamuddin have a large English mansion on a private island situated on Thames river and have remodelled it by adding an indoor pool, home cinema, a private boathouse and a glass house.Does Johnny Depp own islands? ›
He owns a US$5.35 million private island in the Bahamas
When Depp married Heard in 2015, their wedding venue was … his own private island. The 18-hectare (45-acre) island is known as Little Halls Pond Cay and is located in the Exuma Land and Sea Park protected area of the Bahamas.
The islands remained under Danish rule until 1917, when the United States purchased them for $25 million in gold in an effort to improve military positioning during critical times of World War I.
She was promoted to chief deputy attorney general in 2020. She was appointed by governor Albert Bryan to replace Denise George as the acting Attorney General of the United States Virgin Islands on January 1, 2023. In March 2023, Bryan nominated Thomas-Jacobs to the United States Virgin Islands Superior Court.Who is the governor of the US Virgin Islands? ›
Governor Albert Bryan Jr.
As of 1 October 2020, the Attorney General is Dawn Smith.